About Cape May Pizzas
At Cape May Pizzas, we’re proud to serve what many locals and visitors look for when searching for the best pizza in Cape May NJ. Located near the heart of Cape May and close to the beach, we’re a local favorite for handcrafted pizza made with quality ingredients, traditional methods, and a real passion for great food.
We believe exceptional pizza starts with the dough. That’s why we use simple, all-natural, GMO-free ingredients and avoid the preservatives, artificial additives, and shortcuts often found in conventional pizza making. Our crusts are made with unbleached flour and carefully prepared to deliver better texture, better flavor, and a more satisfying pizza experience.
Always Fresh
Our Story
Cape May Pizzas was built on a passion for authentic, high-quality pizza made with clean ingredients and traditional techniques. Our mission is simple: serve the best pizza in Cape May using methods that prioritize flavor, quality, and health-conscious preparation.
We believe pizza should be both indulgent and crafted with care. That’s why we use long fermentation processes, premium ingredients, and time-tested recipes to create a superior pizza experience.
Best burger ideas & traditions from the whole world
Mauris tempus erat laoreet turpis lobortis, eu tincidunt erat fermentum. Aliquam non tincidunt urna. Integer tincidunt nec nisl vitae ullamcorper. Proin sed ultrices erat.
Our Quality
Chicken
Quality is our #1 ingredient. That’s why our Chicken Wings, Chicken Bites and Grilled Chicken Topping are made from chickens raised without antibiotics and fed an all vegetable-grain diet, with no animal by-products. Plus, our Bites are made with 100% chicken breast meat.
Our Quaity
Burger
Some of the world’s best cheese is made close to home! All our deliciously melty Mozzarella is made with 100% Canadian milk. We’re proud to support Canadian dairy farmers.
Our Quaity
What Makes Us Different
- 48-hour fermented dough
- GMO-free ingredients
- No preservatives or artificial additives
- Fresh-made sauce daily
- Unique artisan crust options
Our Quaity
Quality meets perfection
Our slow fermentation process helps create dough that bakes up light, airy, crisp, and full of character. It also allows deeper flavor to develop naturally over time. Whether guests stop in for a casual lunch, pick up dinner after a day at the beach, or order a pie for the whole family, they can count on freshness and consistency in every order.
Cape May Pizzas offers a variety of crust options so everyone can find a favorite. From naturally fermented sourdough and thick, crispy square pies to gluten-free cauliflower crust, we bring together quality ingredients and careful preparation across the menu. The goal is simple: serve memorable pizza that stands out in both taste and quality.
Our Quaity
More Than Pizza — Part of the Cape May Experience
For locals, vacationers, and anyone searching for pizza near Cape May beach, boardwalk pizza in Cape May, or best pizza takeout in Cape May NJ, Cape May Pizza is built to be a go-to destination. We’re more than a pizzeria,we’re part of the Cape May experience.
Our mission is to serve outstanding pizza in a welcoming environment, using better ingredients, thoughtful preparation, and a commitment to quality that shows in every slice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Cape May Pizzas stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients, slow-fermented dough, and carefully crafted crust options. We use simple, all-natural ingredients and focus on delivering a fresh, flavorful pizza experience for both locals and visitors.
Cape May Pizzas is built to be a top choice for anyone looking for the best pizza in Cape May NJ, with handcrafted pies, quality ingredients, and crust options that go beyond the standard pizzeria experience.
Yes. Cape May Pizzas offers a gluten-free cauliflower crust option for guests looking for gluten-free pizza in Cape May.
Cape May Pizzas offers several crust styles, including sourdough, thick square pies with crispy edges, and gluten-free cauliflower crust. Each option is made with a focus on flavor, texture, and quality.
Our dough is crafted with simple ingredients and prepared using a slow fermentation process that helps create better flavor and texture.
Cape May Pizzas is a great choice for anyone looking for pizza near Cape May beach, whether you want dine-in, takeout, or a convenient meal after a day by the water.
Yes. Cape May Pizzas is an excellent option for pizza takeout in Cape May NJ, whether you’re ordering for yourself, your family, or a larger group.
Yes. Cape May Pizzas is a convenient and family-friendly option for locals, seasonal visitors, and vacationers looking for fresh pizza in Cape May.
Our Talented Chefs
We guarantee
30 Minutes Delivery!
Looking for the best pizza in Cape May NJ?
Visit Cape May Pizzas for handcrafted pies, quality ingredients, and a pizza experience made for both locals and visitors. Explore our menu, order online, or stop by and see why Cape May Pizza is becoming a favorite in town.