Cape May’s Best Pizza – Jersey Shore Style, Artisan Crafted

Thin • Crispy • Naturally Fermented Pizza Delivered to the Beach

Thin, crispy, and naturally fermented—crafted for the perfect Jersey Shore bite, with light crunch and bold flavor delivered fresh to the beach.

$12.99

$19.99

Cape May Favorite

Made Fresh Daily

48-Hour Fermented Dough

PICK YOUR CRUST

It's all about the crust

FOUR DISTINCTS STYLES

AUTHENTIC ITALIAN STYLE

Thin . Crispy . Hand-Stretched

SOURDOUGH THIN

48-Hour Cold Fermented . Airy . Chewy

DETROIT STYLE

Thin . Crispy Edge . Square Pie

GLUTEN FREE CAULIFLOWER

Made with Real Cauliflower Crispy . Flavourful

Cape May Inspired Specialty Pizzas

Each pizza is crafted to deliver bold flavors and a unique experience. Our menu features locally inspired specialty pizzas named after iconic Jersey Shore towns:

Pig Out Pie

Sausage, Pepperoni, Bacon, Onions, Green Peppers

Buffalo Chicken

Buffalo Sauce, Fresh Cooked Chicken, Ranch

Congress Hall

Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Peppers, Mushrooms, Red Onions, Mozzarella

Stone Harbor

Spinach, Broccoli, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Garlic

The Avalon

Chicken, Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers, Garlic

Fresh Barbecue Chicken

BBQ Sauce, Chicken, Mozzarella

Sea Isle Hot & Honey

Hot & Honey, Chicken, Mozzarella, Bacon, Ranch

Philly Pizza Steak

Your Choice of Beef or Chicken, Mozzarella, Onions, Green Peppers

Flyin Hawaiian

BBQ Sauce, Bacon, Pineapple, Mozzarella

Wellcome!

Why Cape May Pizzas?

Cape May Pizzas isn’t your average pizzeria. We specialize in artisan, Jersey Shore-style pizza made with clean, natural ingredients and a slow fermentation process that creates a lighter, more flavorful, and easier-to-digest crust.

Unlike traditional pizza shops that rely on processed dough and additives, our dough is fermented for up to 48 hours using unbleached, GMO-free ingredients with no preservatives, no chemicals, and no artificial additives. Every pizza is crafted fresh daily using high-quality toppings and scratch-made sauce.

Delivery

Beach Delivery in Cape May

Enjoy the ultimate shore experience with pizza delivered right to you. Cape May Pizzas offers convenient beach delivery so you can enjoy fresh, hot pizza without leaving your spot in the sand.

Perfect for families, groups, and beach days, our delivery service brings the best pizza in Cape May directly to your towel.

Order Now

Craving the best pizza in Cape May? Order online for pickup or delivery and experience artisan pizza made the right way.

Popular dishes

Get Up to

50%

Off

Hot Fresh

hotdog

What OUR clientS ARE SAYING

All Natural

Pizzas

MADE WITH GMO-FREE
INGREDIENTS 

Famous

Wings

CRISPY & JUICY

Fresh

salads

BEST FRESH SALADS IN CAPE MAY

Updates from Cape may Pizzas